Andy Weir Issues Apology to 'Star Trek' Producer Alex Kurtzman After Calling Modern Shows "Shit"
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MARCH 18: Andy Weir attends "Project Hail Mary" New York premiere at Lincoln Center on March 18, 2026 in New York City. Photo Credit: Dimitrios Kambouris
Author Andy Weir, best known for his bestselling novel "The Martian" and its follow-up "Project Hail Mary", has issued a public apology to Alex Kurtzman, executive producer of several modern Star Trek series, after referring to recent iterations of the franchise as "shit" during a podcast interview.
In response to the online backlash, Weir posted an open letter-style apology on social media platforms, expressing regret for the tone of his comments. He wrote that he did not intend to come across as disrespectful toward Kurtzman or the "Star Trek" team, emphasizing his personal acquaintance with the producer. Weir reiterated that his critique was aimed at specific creative choices rather than a blanket dismissal of all modern "Star Trek" efforts, stating he does not "hate all new takes on the series."
The apology has been characterized by media observers as partial or qualified, as Weir did not retract his core criticisms of the shows' quality nor express remorse for choosing the podcast platform. Coverage noted the timing coincided with Weir's promotional activities for the "Project Hail Mary" film adaptation, suggesting the comments created a minor public relations challenge amid his professional high point.
"Star Trek" under Kurtzman has been a lightning rod for debate among fans, particularly regarding its evolution to include more diverse storytelling, prominent LGBTQ+ characters, and social themes. Series like "Discovery" feature transgender and non-binary representation, such as Adira Tal, a non-binary human character played by Blu del Barrio, and "Star Trek: Prodigy" includes zero-pronoun alien characters, advancing person-first inclusive narratives for LGBTQ+ audiences. These elements have been praised by LGBTQ+ advocates for broadening the franchise's legacy of progressive values initiated by Gene Roddenberry.
No direct responses from Kurtzman or official "Star Trek" Paramount statements have been reported in initial coverage. Fan reactions online have been mixed, with some defending Weir's right to critique while others highlighted the podcast's host as contextually inflammatory. Within LGBTQ+ "Star Trek" communities, discussions have touched on whether Weir's comments indirectly undermine shows valued for their affirming portrayals of transgender people and queer identities, though no organized statements from groups like GLAAD have emerged.
Weir's apology post included a photo from the "Project Hail Mary" premiere, underscoring his current focus on the Amazon MGM Studios adaptation starring Ryan Gosling. The incident underscores ongoing tensions between sci-fi creators and franchise stewards, especially as "Star Trek" prepares for "Starfleet Academy", another Kurtzman-led project.
This event, unfolding over the past few days, highlights the rapid scrutiny public figures face in the digital age, particularly when commenting on culturally significant properties with strong LGBTQ+ representation. Further developments may follow if Kurtzman or "Star Trek" principals respond.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
