Rosie O’Donnell Calls Sydney James Harcourt Her Broadway “Man-Crush”
Photo Credit: Andy Henderson / Jellicle Ball
Rosie O’Donnell used her final night as guest host of Jimmy Kimmel Live! to spotlight Sydney James Harcourt, the Broadway performer who played Rum Tum Tugger in CATS: The Jellicle Ball.
O’Donnell said Harcourt had appeared in Hamilton and The Lion King, while also joking that he had occupied her dreams “every night for the past six weeks.”
She then clarified that her admiration was not a declaration of changed sexual orientation, saying, “I’m still a lesbian,” before adding the comic phrase, “Though tonight, I’m just a little less-bian.”
The segment followed earlier comments from O’Donnell about Harcourt during an interview with comedian Amy Poehler, in which she described him as exceptionally talented and said her admiration did not translate into wanting sexual intimacy with him.
Harcourt’s Role in CATS: The Jellicle Ball
Harcourt’s performance as Rum Tum Tugger was central to O’Donnell’s enthusiasm. The production reimagined Andrew Lloyd Webber’s 1982 musical through the lens of New York City’s underground ballroom scene.
In this staging, Rum Tum Tugger was presented as a swaggering, frequently shirtless character, an interpretation that O’Donnell repeatedly referenced while discussing Harcourt’s performance.The production debuted Off-Broadway at the Perelman Performing Arts Center (PAC NYC) in Lower Manhattan. Following an incredibly successful, heavily extended run, the production officially closed on August 11, 2026.
The critically acclaimed show received nine Drama Desk Award nominations and won three, including Outstanding Revival of a Musical. The production was directed by Zhailon Levingston and Bill Rauch.
O’Donnell’s Five Visits
O’Donnell told Harcourt that she saw CATS: The Jellicle Ball five times during its run.
She said the performances were sold out and included standing ovations during the show.
O’Donnell also recalled seeing Harcourt perform up close after serving as a guest judge, saying she was not prepared for the effect of his performance and joking that she thought she might have a heart attack.
During the late-night appearance, she described her reaction as unexpectedly making her think that “maybe things are different than I already thought.”
Her remarks were framed as humor and admiration rather than a claim about her sexual identity.
Harcourt on Confidence and Representation
During the interview, O’Donnell told Harcourt that she could not take her eyes off him onstage and praised him as both a singer and a dancer.
Harcourt said he initially felt pressure to perform what he believed “the sexiest cat” should look like.
He said an associate encouraged him to stop trying so hard, after which he began experimenting with doing less rather than exaggerating the character’s sex appeal.
According to Harcourt, the audience response grew stronger as he relaxed into the role, leading him to realize that he could simply be himself.
He described the production as the kind of representational work he wanted to pursue and said the show could make a major impact.
Harcourt also said he had grown up painfully awkward and shy and had been bullied.
He connected his work as Rum Tum Tugger with developing greater confidence and discovering a sense of personal swagger.
The Interview’s Broader Context
The exchange aired during O’Donnell’s fourth and final night filling in for Jimmy Kimmel.
ABC’s schedule identified Harcourt as a guest on the August 20 episode alongside Megan Mullally, Nick Offerman and Shawn Hatosy.
Harcourt’s appearance was also promoted as an interview about CATS: The Jellicle Ball, the production’s closing and his appearance in Playgirl.
The actor also released his first single, “Deviant,” on August 20, according to the interview coverage.
For O’Donnell, the appearance combined a farewell to a recently closed Broadway production with a comic tribute to a performer whose work had made a strong impression on her.
For Harcourt, the conversation offered an opportunity to discuss the artistic choices behind Rum Tum Tugger and the personal confidence he said the role helped him develop.
The segment’s central joke remained consistent throughout: O’Donnell’s “man-crush” was presented as platonic, while her admiration for Harcourt’s stage presence was unmistakable.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
