InFrame

Kelly Clarkson Backs AI Music—If It Has Its Own Chart

Photo Credit: Las Culturistas

by Chris Tremblay  Oct 2

Kelly Clarkson said she “loves AI,” but believes AI-generated artists should not compete directly with human musicians on the same music charts. She made the remarks during an appearance on "Las Culturistas", the podcast hosted by Bowen Yang and Matt Rogers, in an episode released September 30.

Clarkson made her case during the show’s “I Don’t Think So, Honey” segment, where she offered a brief argument about AI. She said she was “very into it artistically” and enjoyed experimenting with it, but objected to AI artists “competing on a chart with humans.”

“I think there should be a separate chart,” Clarkson said. She described AI as “welcome to the table” and said it could enable people who “maybe can’t do certain things” to create music.

Her position, as reported from the podcast, was not a call to exclude AI from music altogether. Instead, she argued that human and AI-generated work should be distinguishable and that each could have an audience. “We can’t lose human,” she said, while adding that “there could be an appetite for both.”

Clarkson compared the prospect of AI artists competing against human performers to robots competing with people in the Olympics, asking rhetorically who would throw an object farther. The analogy framed her objection as one of categories and comparison, rather than a rejection of all AI-assisted creativity.

A debate over categories and disclosure



Clarkson’s comments arrive as the music business grapples with how to identify and account for songs made with AI. On August 25, "Billboard" said it was committed to greater transparency around AI use, including identifying songs using AI on its charts and in its editorial coverage.

That announcement described an identification and transparency approach; it did not announce that AI-generated music would be placed on separate charts. "The Hollywood Reporter" likewise reported that AI-generated music had not been banned from "Billboard" and noted the publication’s commitment to identifying songs that use AI.

The distinction matters: labeling a song’s use of AI can inform audiences and chart readers, while assigning AI-generated music to a separate chart would change how those songs are ranked against one another. Clarkson’s comments addressed the latter question, but her proposal does not itself establish a charting policy or indicate that "Billboard" will adopt one.

"Billboard" said that greater transparency from artists and creators, combined with reliable tools for identifying AI-generated music, would be important to its effort. It also pointed to the development of tools and initiatives, including Luminate’s announced AI-detection program.

The chart question therefore involves more than a proposed division between human and AI work. Identifying the presence of AI, deciding how much AI use merits a label, and determining which songs qualify for a given chart are related but separate issues; the sources reporting Clarkson’s remarks and "Billboard"’s policy announcement describe transparency commitments, not a settled universal standard.

What Clarkson said—and what she did not



Clarkson described AI’s potential in broad, positive terms, saying it could be “really cool and creative” and pointing to its possible use by people who may not be able to do certain things without such tools. She also said AI was not going away and praised its use in scientific work.

At the same time, she said she did not want AI artists competing with human performers on the same chart. Her proposed solution was a separate ranking, allowing listeners to engage with both forms of music without treating them as directly interchangeable in a single chart category.

The available reporting does not establish that Clarkson’s comments were a formal policy proposal to a chart company, nor does it report a response from "Billboard" to her specific suggestion. Her remarks were made in a podcast conversation, and the separate-chart idea should be understood as her stated view rather than an announced industry change.

For now, the contrast is between Clarkson’s preference for separate chart categories and "Billboard"’s stated commitment to disclose AI use in its charts and coverage. The conversation highlights an unresolved question for the music industry: how best to make AI’s role visible while ranking music made through different creative processes.

Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Noah Schnapp’s 'Affluenza' Releases First Production Photos as London Run Extends

Photo Credit: Danny Kaan For Production

by Chris Tremblay  Oct 2

New production photographs from "Affluenza", starring Noah Schnapp, were released on October 2, offering a first look at the show onstage at Riverside Studios in London.

Quavo Talks New Album, Fatherhood, Viral 'Hotel Lobby' and Working on Migos Project With Offset

Quavo poses for a portrait on Wednesday, Sept. 30, 2026, in Los Angeles. Photo Credit: AP Photo/Chris Pizzello

by Jonathan Landrum Jr.  Oct 2

Quavo has spent much of his career setting trends. These days, he’s more focused on what will last.

At Paris Fashion Week, Chloé Bets on Stars, Lingerie and Lace in a Tougher Luxury Market

Claudia Schiffer attends the Chloe Womenswear Spring Summer 2027 collection presented in Paris, Thursday, Oct. 1, 2026. Photo Credit: AP Photo/Aurelien Morissard

by Thomas Adamson  Oct 1

Claire Danes, Cynthia Erivo and Claudia Schiffer joined the morning crowd at the 17th-century Paris Observatory on Thursday as Chloé sent lingerie, lace and fishermen’s coats down the runway at Paris Fashion Week.

Victoria Monét’s ‘Frequency of Love’ Aims to Strike the Optimal Sonic Vibration

Victoria Monét poses for a portrait in New York on Wednesday, Sept. 9, 2026. Photo Credit: Photo by Andy Kropa/Invision/AP

by Gary Gerard Hamilton  Oct 1

Victoria Monét won’t take it personally if you call her upcoming album a comeback, even though it has only been a three-year break.

Jennifer Lopez in the Rain, Dolphins on T-Shirts: Stella Mccartney Declares War on Seafood in Paris

Jennifer Lopez arrives for the Stella McCartney Womenswear Spring Summer 2027 collection presented in Paris, France, Wednesday, Sept. 30, 2026. Photo Credit: AP Photo/Aurelien Morissard

by Thomas Adamson  Oct 1

Stella McCartney declared war on the fishing industry at Paris Fashion Week on Wednesday, 25 years into a label that has never used leather, fur or feathers — on a rain-soaked runway in the British ambassador's gardens, with Jennifer Lopez under an umbrella in the front row.

Stallone at 80 Reflects on 'Rocky' 50 Years Later: 'I Am a Lucky Dog'

Photo Credit: MGM

by Hillel Italie  Oct 1

Fifty years after Sylvester Stallone pulled off one of Hollywood's all-time long shots with “Rocky,” the Oscar-winning star still identifies with the character who for many embodies the outsider proving all the naysayers wrong.

'Verity' Puts Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson and Josh Hartnett in a Steamy Colleen Hoover Thriller

This image released by Amazon/MGM Studios shows Anne Hathaway in a scene from "Verity." Photo Credit: Alisha Wetherill/Amazon/MGM Studios via AP

by Lindsey Bahr  Oct 1

In “Verity,” it’s hard to know who to trust.

Still Doing The Time Warp: Patricia Quinn Reflects on Five Decades of 'Rocky Horror'

Photo Credit: Fox

by Steve Duffy  Sep 29

More than 50 years after Patricia Quinn first stepped into the role of Magenta, The Rocky Horror Picture Show remains a cultural phenomenon unlike any other. What began as a tiny London stage production grew into a celebration of individuality, self-expression, and acceptance that continues to inspire generations of fans. I spoke with Quinn about creating Magenta, working with Tim Curry and Richard O'Brien, Rocky Horror's special connection with the LGBTQ+ community, and why its fans' extraordinary devotion still amazes her today.

Miley Cyrus’ "Bass Persuades" Debuts at No. 1 on the Billboard 200

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 05: Miley Cyrus attends the 2025 Met Gala Celebrating "Superfine: Tailoring Black Style" at Metropolitan Museum of Art on May 05, 2025 in New York City. Photo Credit: Dia Dipasupil

by Chris Tremblay  Sep 29

Miley Cyrus’ "Bass Persuades" debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 chart dated Oct. 3, marking her first album to reach the summit in more than a decade.