Jesse Tyler Ferguson Recalls Being “Really Traumatized” on Halloween Hayride With Full 'Glee' Cast
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - JUNE 16: Jesse Tyler Ferguson attends the 77th Annual Tony Awards at David H. Koch Theater at Lincoln Center on June 16, 2024 in New York City.Photo Credit: Eugene Gologursky/Getty Images for Tony Awards Productions
Modern Family star Jesse Tyler Ferguson has revisited a particularly intense Halloween outing from the early days of his sitcom career, revealing that a haunted hayride with the full cast of Glee left him “really traumatized” and in tears. Speaking on the April 21 episode of his podcast Dinner’s On Me, Ferguson told guest Jeff Hiller that the seemingly fun Hollywood night out quickly became overwhelming once the group tried to extend the evening into a dark corn maze.
Setting the scene: Glee, Modern Family, and a haunted hayride
Ferguson explained that the outing took place shortly after Modern Family had begun, at a time when both his show and Fox’s musical dramedy Glee were at the center of U.S. television culture. Both series premiered in 2009, bringing prominent LGBTQ+ storylines and characters into millions of homes, with Ferguson portraying one half of a gay couple on Modern Family and several Glee characters also representing queer youth.
In his retelling, Ferguson recalls being invited to a Los Angeles haunted hayride with the “whole cast of Glee,” describing the set‑up as “so Hollywood” because it involved two hit shows intersecting at a themed attraction. The Haunted Hayride attraction, a longstanding seasonal event in Los Angeles, takes visitors through a series of horror‑themed zones staffed by performers in grotesque costumes who rush toward the wagon to deliver jump scares.
Ferguson said that, on paper, the hayride portion seemed manageable because participants sit together on a moving flatbed, which allowed him to feel relatively secure. The actor told Hiller that he intentionally stayed in the center of the hayride “vessel,” away from its edges, to avoid the performers who ran up from the dark toward the sides of the truck.
From controlled scares to a breaking point
Even with those precautions, Ferguson admitted that the hayride pushed his fear threshold, saying it was “enough” on its own in terms of adrenaline and stress. In the podcast discussion, he linked the intensity of such events to lingering effects, telling Hiller that he can remain on edge for “a week and a half” after attending horror attractions like Universal’s Halloween Horror Nights.
The real emotional tipping point came when the group suggested doing a corn maze after completing the hayride, a proposal Ferguson said he did not want any part of. According to his account, the corn maze sent participants in alone or in small groups armed only with a lantern, transforming the experience from a shared ride into an isolated, immersive horror scenario.
Ferguson told listeners that he repeatedly said, “I can’t do it, I can’t do it,” as his husband Justin Mikita encouraged him to give the maze a chance and the Glee performers tried to rally everyone to participate. In his recollection of the moment, he described the cast of Glee as “all like, let’s go,” which contrasted sharply with his growing sense that he had already done “enough” and needed to step away.
Ultimately, the pressure and fear combined to the point where Ferguson began to cry, telling the podcast audience that he broke down as he opted out of the maze and walked back toward his car instead. He summed up the incident by saying he was “really traumatized” by the overall experience, highlighting how quickly a festive group outing can morph into an ordeal when someone’s boundaries are pushed too far.
Humor, imagined reactions, and queer camaraderie
Even as he recounted the emotional intensity, Ferguson framed many details with a light, self‑aware tone, joking about the “so Hollywood” nature of being on a haunted hayride with another major TV cast. At one point, he playfully imagined how Glee star Lea Michele might have responded to his fear, joking that she would have told him to “grow a pair” as the rest of the ensemble encouraged him toward the maze.
Throughout the episode, Ferguson and Hiller—both openly gay performers whose work has contributed to more expansive portrayals of LGBTQ+ people on television—used the story as a springboard for a broader conversation about horror attractions and anxiety. Hiller, who won an Emmy for his role on Somebody Somewhere, spoke about the difficulty of “turning off” after such high‑adrenaline events, while Ferguson agreed that the lingering impact can be “traumatizing” even when everyone knows the scares are staged.
Ferguson and Hiller also reflected on the fact that both Glee and Modern Family premiered in 2009 and have since concluded, with Glee ending in 2015 and Modern Family wrapping up in 2020. The pair used that passage of time to underscore how far their careers and LGBTQ+ representation on television have come since the early days when a promotional Halloween event with another hit cast felt like a novelty.
From “Cocaine Bear” to coping with fear
Despite his sensitivity to immersive horror attractions, Ferguson is no stranger to screen projects that traffic in gore and fright, having appeared in the 2023 horror‑comedy film Cocaine Bear. In the podcast conversation, he noted that he has not yet acted in a more traditional, straight‑horror movie, suggesting that his on‑screen experiences with fear differ significantly from real‑world haunted mazes and hayrides.
The actor’s candid admission of crying and feeling overwhelmed during the hayride outing offers a counter‑narrative to stereotypes that equate bravery with suppressing emotion, particularly for men and queer people in the public eye. By sharing the story in a humorous but honest way, he models how celebrities and LGBTQ+ community members can talk openly about anxiety, boundaries, and the importance of opting out when something no longer feels fun or safe.
Listeners to Dinner’s On Me heard Ferguson use self‑deprecation and vivid detail to turn a personal low point—crying while walking back alone to his car on what was supposed to be a glamorous Halloween hang—into a communal joke and a reflection on consent in social situations. The story also highlights the sometimes‑unseen emotional dynamics behind celebrity group outings, where enthusiastic peers, partners, and co‑stars may have very different thresholds for fear and risk, especially in environments designed to push people past their comfort zones.
Ferguson’s anecdote, now circulating in entertainment coverage and social feeds, adds another layer to his public persona as a gay actor, producer, and advocate who has long blended comedy with candor about vulnerability. As Halloween fans and viewers revisit old episodes of Glee and Modern Family, his “really traumatized” hayride story offers both a behind‑the‑scenes glimpse of TV‑era camaraderie and a reminder that everyone, including beloved LGBTQ+ entertainers, can hit a hard limit when the scares stop feeling playful.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
