'Heated Rivalry' Cottage Owner Agrees to Season 2 Return After “Soul Searching”
Photo Credit: HBO
Michael Kutryk, a Toronto-based doctor, has identified himself as the owner of the waterfront Muskoka cottage used in the Season 1 finale of Heated Rivalry. The cottage, located in Ontario’s Muskoka region, became the setting for “The Cottage,” the episode in which professional hockey players Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov retreat from public attention. The characters are played by Hudson Williams and Connor Storrie, respectively.
The home has three bedrooms and three bathrooms and is surrounded by trees on the waterfront. It was designed by Toronto architect Trevor McIvor, whose connection to the production helped a location scout reach Kutryk.
A larger production than expected
Kutryk said producers initially told him Heated Rivalry had a “very small budget” and offered him “almost nothing” to use the property. He agreed, but said he nearly changed his mind when black sport-utility vehicles and production equipment began arriving at the cottage.
Crew members indicated where portable toilets and an outdoor kitchen would be placed, prompting Kutryk to realize that the shoot would involve more people and equipment than he had anticipated. He estimated that approximately 45 people were involved in the filming, which he said may be small by film-production standards but did not feel small to him.
Kutryk said the producers assured him that filming would take place over two weekdays, when he would not normally be using the property. He ultimately allowed the production to proceed and was not present during the shoot.
What viewers saw
Kutryk said the production changed very little inside the home. He said most of the furniture and other possessions shown on screen belonged to him.
The production removed artwork because displaying it could have required payments to the artists whose work appeared on screen. A mattress was also replaced for a bedroom scene involving Shane and Ilya.
Kutryk said he learned more about the intimate nature of the series after listening to the audiobook on which it was based, Rachel Reid’s hockey romance novel. He said the book’s explicit content made him wonder what the production would film and show, but he ultimately accepted that the producers would make their own creative decisions.
Heated Rivalry is a sports-romance television series produced for Canadian broadcaster Crave and HBO Max. Its central relationship follows two male hockey players whose private romantic relationship develops alongside their professional careers.
The Season 2 decision
Kutryk said the production contacted him about using the cottage again for Season 2. “I did a little bit of soul searching about allowing them to come back,” he told HGTV.
He said he understood that the production needed the location but did not want to exploit its position during negotiations. When the production asked how much he wanted, Kutryk first mentioned that a table had been scratched and then named what he called a “very reasonable price.”
According to Kutryk, the producers were shocked and appreciative of the amount. He said he did not require them to replace the table. The exact payment and the cost of any repair were not disclosed in the published interview.
Variety and Deadline separately reported Kutryk’s comments about weighing the Season 2 decision and his continuing reluctance to treat the property primarily as a commercial asset.
Privacy versus public interest
Kutryk said the cottage was built as a retreat from everyday life. “I’m a private guy,” he said. “This is my retreat. I built this to get away from the world, so I don’t know how much longer I’ll continue to share it.”
His comments place the Season 2 agreement within a broader question about how long a private residence can remain connected to a widely watched television series. Kutryk said he would assess future demand after Season 2 airs rather than committing publicly to an indefinite arrangement.
The cottage had already become part of the show’s commercial afterlife after being offered as a vacation rental through Airbnb. Airbnb collaborated with the property owner, while Jayne’s Luxury Rentals helped manage bookings. The rental arrangement expanded from an initial proposal involving four weekends in May to a period extending through the summer and into the fall.
Kutryk said the rental arrangement was “an offer too good to refuse,” but the amount was not published. He also said he expected to use the property again in winter, a season he associates with activities including ice fishing and snowshoeing.
What happens next
The immediate development is that the real-life cottage will appear in the production’s second season after Kutryk agreed to its return. His comments do not establish how prominently the property will feature in the season or whether it will remain available for vacation rentals afterward.
For now, Kutryk’s position is conditional rather than permanent: he has permitted another production visit, while reserving the right to reconsider future filming and rentals. “We’ll see after Season 2 airs what demand is like,” he said.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
