Harry Shum Jr. Defends His “Dancing With the Stars” Casting
Photo Credit: Disney
Harry Shum Jr. is defending his decision to join Dancing With the Stars after viewers questioned whether his professional dance background gives him an unfair advantage in the competition.
Shum is widely associated with dance-focused performances, including his role as Mike Chang on Glee and appearances in the Step Up film franchise. ABC’s cast announcement described him as an actor, dancer, producer and publisher, and identified him as a current star of Grey’s Anatomy.
Those credits prompted criticism from some viewers who argued that Shum, along with other contestants who have prior dance experience, could enter the show with an advantage over celebrities who have never performed professionally. The criticism focused on the distinction between a celebrity contestant’s previous dance training and the specialized ballroom and Latin techniques taught on the program.
Shum’s Response
Speaking with People at Good Morning America on September 2, Shum rejected the assumption that experience in one dance style automatically transfers to every other style.
“I think everyone’s idea is like, ‘Oh, you dance, so you should be able to dance anything,’” Shum said. “And I mean, that’s just not true.”
“There are hundreds of styles, not dozens, hundreds all over the world,” he added.
Shum acknowledged that he has a background in dance but said Johnson has a stronger understanding of the craft relevant to the competition. He characterized the partnership as an opportunity to work toward Johnson’s level rather than as evidence that he already possesses the same expertise.
In a separate interview reported by The Express, Shum described ballroom and Latin dance as “a whole new vocabulary” for him. He said Johnson was teaching him the techniques required for the show and that he was approaching the competition as a challenge.
The distinction Shum described is central to the dispute: his previous work demonstrates performance and dance experience, but it does not establish that he has professional-level training in every discipline represented on Dancing With the Stars.
The Judge’s Defense of the Cast
Carrie Ann Inaba, one of the show’s judges, also addressed complaints about contestants with previous dance experience.
Inaba said that moving from jazz, hip-hop or other dance forms into ballroom can require major technical adjustments, particularly in relation to weight placement. “What’s difficult—and I don’t think people realize this—is when you go from being a jazz dancer or a hip-hop dancer or all the other forms of dancing to ballroom, the weight placement is so different,” Inaba said, according to Entertainment Weekly.
Inaba’s comments placed Shum’s defense within a broader discussion about how the show evaluates celebrities who arrive with different kinds of performance experience. The issue also involved Jenna Dewan and Julia Stiles, whose previous dance or performance backgrounds prompted similar questions from viewers.
Why the Debate Matters to the Competition
Dancing With the Stars pairs celebrities with professional dancers, who teach and perform choreographed routines across ballroom and Latin categories. The professional partners are responsible for choreography and instruction, while the celebrity contestants are judged on their execution, musicality, technique and performance during the season.
Because the celebrity lineup includes people with different levels and types of performance experience, comparisons between contestants are part of the program’s public discussion. However, the available reporting does not establish that Shum has an unfair competitive advantage, nor does it show that his prior dance work guarantees a particular result.
Shum’s own comments emphasized the limits of transferring experience between dance forms rather than denying his professional history. His position is that being comfortable with movement, choreography or performance does not mean being equally trained in ballroom and Latin technique.
The debate was still developing as the Season 35 premiere aired. Reports published after the premiere said the season had already reached its first elimination, although coverage also reported an ABC voting outage.
The Next Test
For Shum, the question is no longer only whether his casting is fair but how quickly he can adapt his existing performance skills to the show’s technical demands. His partnership with Johnson places that adaptation process at the center of his Season 35 storyline.
The evidence available from Shum, Inaba and ABC supports a narrower conclusion than either side of the online debate: Shum has significant experience as a performer and dancer, but the show presents ballroom and Latin dance as distinct technical disciplines that he must learn with Johnson’s instruction.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
