James Lafferty Says He’ll Join ‘Dancing With the Stars’—If Fans Push His Netflix Show Into the Top 10
Photo Credit: James Lafferty / Instagram
James Lafferty has publicly thrown his name into the mix for Dancing With the Stars Season 35, but only if viewers rally around his Netflix series Everyone Is Doing Great. In TikTok videos posted in May, the actor told fans he would “come do Dancing With the Stars and be happy to do Dancing With the Stars” if Everyone Is Doing Great cracks the Top 10 TV shows on Netflix in the United States.
From Hesitation To ‘I’m Down’
Initially, Lafferty did not sound eager to step onto a live television dance floor, stressing that his value on Dancing With the Stars would likely be “not so much for the competition aspect, but for the comedy aspect.” Speaking about the idea in an initial TikTok Q&A, he joked that fans have already witnessed some of his dancing—on One Tree Hill and in Everyone Is Doing Great—and hinted that the results were more entertaining than impressive.
Lafferty also framed the DWTS concept as strong story material for his character Jeremy in a potential third season of Everyone Is Doing Great, describing a fictional arc where the struggling former teen star attempts a reality‑competition comeback. However, in a follow‑up video replying to professional DWTS dancer Ezra Sosa—who had commented that Lafferty was “hot” and that he was “down” for the idea—the actor shifted tone, telling Sosa he had been thinking about it and now wanted to do the show.
In that second TikTok, Lafferty declared, “Yeah I’m gonna do Dancing With the Stars. I’m down,” but immediately attached the caveat that Everyone Is Doing Great must reach Netflix’s U.S. Top 10 TV ranking first. He said he wanted “both things to happen”—success for the series and a chance to work on his dancing—with the help of professional partner Sosa, adding that he sees this arrangement as a situation where “everybody wins.”
The One Condition: Netflix Top 10
Lafferty’s condition is straightforward: he will accept a Dancing With the Stars offer if Everyone Is Doing Great appears in the Top 10 TV shows on Netflix in the United States. In his TikTok message, he repeated that this chart position is “my condition” and that he would be “happy” to take part in the ABC competition if the benchmark is met.
The actor encouraged fans to stream both existing seasons of Everyone Is Doing Great, to use Netflix’s thumbs‑up function on the show’s title page, and to spread the word among friends to help push the series up the platform’s internal charts. The Blast reports that he positioned viewership and engagement as crucial levers, suggesting that sustained watch time and positive ratings could influence the series’ visibility and chances at further seasons.
Everyone Is Doing Great, created by Lafferty and fellow One Tree Hill alum Stephen Colletti, follows two former co‑stars grappling with fading fame and personal setbacks several years after the end of their hit television series. In the series, Lafferty plays Jeremy, a character whose stalled career and complicated relationships mirror some of the pressures real‑world actors face in a changing industry.
Streaming, Fandom, And The DWTS Machine
Season 1 of Everyone Is Doing Great originally premiered on streaming before making its way to Netflix, and Seasons 1 and 2 were added to Netflix’s catalog on May 11, 2026. The arrival on the global platform gives the show access to a larger potential audience, including many One Tree Hill fans who followed Lafferty and Colletti from their teen drama days.
By tying his possible DWTS participation to the show’s performance, Lafferty effectively mobilizes that fan base around a measurable streaming goal. Entertainment Now notes that social media interaction around his TikTok videos has already sparked conversation among viewers who are eager to see him in the ballroom and who are willing to binge the series to help make it happen.
Dancing With the Stars, now preparing for Season 35, has a long history of casting actors from fan‑beloved television series and using their built‑in followings to drive engagement. The Express points out that Lafferty would become the third One Tree Hill alum to compete on the show if he joins, following previous cast members from the drama who have taken a turn on the dance floor.
ABC’s ballroom competition also has a track record of featuring a wide range of public figures and entertainers, including LGBTQ+ celebrities and professional dancers, and framing their stories as part of a broader narrative about resilience, visibility, and self‑expression. Within that environment, Lafferty’s stated interest in learning to dance—while embracing the comedic potential of his inexperience—fits into a familiar pattern of contestants who join the show to confront fears, learn new skills, and share personal journeys with viewers.
‘Terrible Dancer’ Narrative And Self‑Improvement
Lafferty has repeatedly described himself as a “terrible” dancer, using the term in a self‑deprecating way to explain why his potential DWTS run would be as much about growth as about competition. The Express recounts his comments about viewers having seen him dance before in earlier projects and his belief that while he might not excel technically, the performance would be entertaining.
In speaking about working with Ezra Sosa, Lafferty emphasized that collaboration with a professional partner could help him “fix” his dancing, suggesting that the potential season would double as an intensive training experience. This framing aligns with the show’s tradition of featuring contestants who arrive with little or no dance background and work closely with professionals to improve week by week.
His light‑hearted remarks also acknowledge the role of humor and vulnerability in the series, where contestants are often candid about their limitations and rely on audience support as they learn. For viewers, particularly LGBTQ+ audiences who value spaces that celebrate authenticity and personal growth, the idea of a well‑known actor confronting a perceived weakness on national television may resonate as another example of embracing imperfection in a public arena.
No Official Casting—Yet
Despite the flurry of speculation around his TikTok posts, there has been no official confirmation that Lafferty has been cast on Dancing With the Stars Season 35. Parade notes that the show typically reveals its final lineup closer to the fall premiere, and that Lafferty’s participation depends on both casting decisions and whether his condition involving the Netflix Top 10 is ultimately met.
Entertainment Now reports that Season 35 is scheduled to debut this fall on ABC, with the full cast announcement expected around the premiere window. As of mid‑May 2026, coverage in multiple outlets stresses that Lafferty’s involvement remains conditional and hypothetical, subject both to fan‑driven streaming outcomes and to the show’s own casting choices.
A Feedback Loop Between Star And Fans
Lafferty’s public condition illustrates how contemporary performers often leverage a feedback loop between their personal brand, social‑media presence, and the fate of scripted projects they care about. By promising to say yes to a high‑profile reality competition in exchange for streaming support, he invites fans into a participatory relationship where their viewing choices could influence both his next career move and the trajectory of Everyone Is Doing Great.
Coverage across outlets underscores that this arrangement is less a formal campaign than an open challenge, delivered in an informal TikTok exchange but quickly amplified by entertainment media. Whether or not the Netflix Top 10 condition is met, the conversation has already spotlighted the series and highlighted Lafferty’s willingness to step outside his comfort zone—on the ballroom floor and in the evolving relationship between artists, audiences, and platforms.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
