Justice Smith Challenges Rigid Gender Expectations and ‘Hypermasculine’ Pressure Faced by Black Queer Men
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 05: Justice Smith attends the 2025 Met Gala Celebrating "Superfine: Tailoring Black Style" at Metropolitan Museum of Art on May 05, 2025 in New York City. Photo Credit: Savion Washington
Justice Smith has spoken about pressures around masculinity and gender expression, saying that as a Black man he felt heightened expectations to be hypermasculine. The "Heated Rivalry" season two actor’s comments were reported by "Attitude" on October 26, following remarks shared on social media that day.
He also credited his father with helping him accept qualities commonly associated with femininity, including softness, vulnerability, strength and creativity. Smith said that, after realizing he was queer, he experienced social permission to embrace femininity, which he described as powerful in light of pressure on Black men to be hypermasculine.
The comments address more than one expectation: Smith described both the pressure he associated with being a Black man and the judgments he said he encountered as a queer man. His account, as reported by "Attitude", was personal; it does not establish that every Black queer man has the same experience.
Criticism over gender expression
Smith said that after coming out, he faced criticism when he wanted to express traits conventionally understood as masculine. According to the report, he said that some people accused him of “lying,” being “disingenuous” or being “self-hating” as a queer man.
He connected those reactions to what he described as sexism: “the dismissal and dehumanisation of women and femininity.” Smith argued that this dynamic can damage the possibility of a healthy understanding of masculinity.
Smith also cautioned against treating masculinity as inherently negative. He said that queer men may “bristle” at masculine presentation when they see it as a return to restrictive norms, but that rejecting masculinity outright can create another limitation on gender expression.
His stated position, as reported, was that people should be able to find their own balance of masculine and feminine qualities. That framing does not require any one person to adopt a particular presentation; it argues against restricting how others express themselves.
The conversation and its limits
"Attitude" described Smith’s social-media remarks as prompting an “in-house” conversation about masculinity and gender expression, and its report embeds a post shared by Crave’s account .
The report centers on Smith’s own account and quotations. It does not provide independent research or data measuring how common the experiences he described are, so his statements should be understood as his perspective rather than as a population-wide finding.
Smith’s comments also distinguish between challenging narrow gender expectations and prescribing a new rule for queer men. He described criticism from people who interpreted his masculine traits as inconsistent with being queer, while arguing that treating masculinity as wholly negative can impose a different restriction.
Smith’s role in *Heated Rivalry*
Smith is set to play Harris Drover in the second season of "Heated Rivalry", according to "Attitude". The publication describes Drover as an openly gay social-media manager for the Ottawa Centaurs hockey team and says Charlie Gillespie will play Troy Barrett.
The casting links Smith’s remarks about queer identity and gender expression with a prominent upcoming television role, but the comments reported by "Attitude" were about his personal experiences, not a statement about the series or his character.
In describing his own relationship to masculinity, Smith emphasized that traits such as softness and vulnerability can coexist with strength and assertiveness. His broader appeal was for room to express both masculine and feminine qualities without being judged as less authentic for doing so.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
