Justice Smith Promises to “Take Good Care” of Harris After 'Heated Rivalry' Casting Backlash
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 05: Justice Smith attends the 2025 Met Gala Celebrating "Superfine: Tailoring Black Style" at Metropolitan Museum of Art on May 05, 2025 in New York City. Photo Credit: Savion Washington
Justice Smith and Charlie Gillespie have been cast as Harris Drover and Troy Barrett, respectively, in the second season of Heated Rivalry, the Canadian romantic drama distributed by Crave in Canada and HBO Max in the United States.
Crave said Smith will portray Harris, the Ottawa Centaurs’ social media manager, while Gillespie will play Troy, a hockey player who joins the team.
The second season is scheduled to premiere in spring 2027, and production had begun by the time of the announcement.
The season is based on Role Model, the fifth book in Rachel Reid’s Game Changers series.
Smith Addresses Fans
Following the announcement, Smith addressed the reaction in an Instagram Story.
“I am moved by the support and love I’m getting from fans in my DMs, fans who have welcomed me with open arms and who already feel a responsibility to protect me,” Smith wrote, according to Deadline.
He then referred directly to the character he will play, writing: “I am honored to play a character that you all care about deeply and I promise that I will take good care of him if you give me the chance.”
Smith ended the message by saying he was “beyond excited for the experience.”
The post came after online criticism directed at the casting announcement, including comments focused on whether Smith’s appearance corresponded with some readers’ interpretation of Harris.
Why Fans Debated the Casting
In Role Model, Harris is described as stocky and as having a soft belly, while the character also refers to himself as “pudgy.”
Those descriptions led some readers to imagine Harris as having a larger build than Smith.
The criticism was framed by those fans as a concern about body representation and fidelity to the source material rather than as a judgment of Smith’s acting ability.
The debate also included reactions to Gillespie’s casting as Troy, with some discussion about whether the actors’ physical appearances matched readers’ expectations of the characters.
Other fans expressed support for Smith and Gillespie and interest in seeing the actors interpret the couple on screen.
Reid and Producers Defend the Decision
Reid appeared to respond to the criticism through an Instagram Story after the casting news was published.
“Thinking about all the people last summer who told me the casting for Ilya and Shane was wrong and bad…,” Reid wrote, according to Just Jared.
The message referred to earlier doubts about the casting of Storrie and Williams as Ilya and Shane in the first season.
Show creator Jacob Tierney and executive producer Brendan Brady also defended the selection of Smith and Gillespie in a statement reported by Just Jared.
“From the start of the casting process, we knew we were looking for actors who could create something truly special together and bring that same depth and heart to the screen,” Tierney and Brady said.
“Justice and Charlie do exactly that,” they added.
The producers said the actors connected with the vulnerability and resilience at the center of Harris and Troy’s stories and demonstrated an instinctive understanding of the characters.
The Story Ahead
According to Variety, the television series’ version of Troy is a hockey player who is traded to Ottawa after breaking with a former friend and teammate in Toronto who is accused of sexual assault.
Harris, meanwhile, works for the Ottawa team and becomes determined to draw Troy out of his shell.
The characters’ relationship is the central romance of Role Model, the novel that provides the season’s primary source material.
The casting response therefore reflects two distinct expectations among fans: anticipation for a new queer romance within the series and concern about how closely the adaptation will follow readers’ established images of the characters.
Smith’s statement did not address the body-representation criticism in detail, but it did acknowledge the intensity of fans’ attachment to Harris and ask viewers to give him an opportunity in the role.
Season 2 is expected to bring Smith and Gillespie into the show’s established ensemble alongside Storrie and Williams when the series returns in spring 2027.
Copyright EDGE Media Network. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
